Sign up for free to use this document yourself.
  • #Z's Think-Writing File

  • #Things to Think through via Writing
    #↓

  • #→
    @RSM, @research action
    #- Idea: Use Toulmin's (sp?) claim-reason-evidence-warrant structure to guide my reasoning about and explanation of my rough, initial, hypothesized program theory as well as my final, revised, evidence-informed program theory

  • @writing, @revising
    #My Proposal Tables, Images, and Appendices

  • #`My Awesome Zeroeth Draft`
    #↓

  • {introductory paragraphs}

  • Background of the Study

  • Statement of the Problem

  • Purpose and Rationale of the Study

  • Research Question and Review Questions

  • Central Research Question

  • Review Questions

  • Some Hypotheses

  • Definition of Key Terms

  • {preview: list of main sections and subsections}

  • #Booth (2008), p. 109
    Claim-reason-evidence-warrant:
    “. . . every argument, research or not, is built out of answers to five questions . . . questions that you must ask yourself on your reader’s behalf:

    • What is my claim?
    • What reasons support my claim?
    • What evidence supports my reasons?
    • What principle makes my reasons relevant to my claim? (We call this principle a warrant.)”
      #↓
  • #Research Design →
    #↓

  • Realist Synthesis Methodology

  • Overview (description) of Realist Synthesis Methdology

  • Assumptions under Realist Synthesis Methdology

  • Key Concepts in Realist Synthesis Methodology

  • Stages in Realist Synthesis Methodology

  • Challenges with Employing Realist Synthesis Methodology

  • Strengths of Realist Synthesis

  • Rationale for Employing Realist Synthesis

  • Methods

  • Ethical Considerations

  • Scope and Delimitations

    (factors under the control of the researcher)

  • Limitations

    (factors NOT under the control of the researcher)

  • Assumptions

    (factors that the researcher assumes are taken into consideration)

  • External Validity (Generalizability)

  • Internal Validity (Reliability)

  • . . . THEREFORE, regarding my claim as to my hypothesized, rough, initial program theory

    • I claim that ONE mechanism underlying bar diagramming is that it affords subjects the OPPORTUNITY to “add leaves to their realization trees” by engaging in MR (multimodal representation)
    • REASONS: distributed cognition; theory of binumeracy; appropriation of sign; UMR SOLO cycle; diagram-gesture-agency theory; embodied cognition in mathematics
    • PRINCIPLES: the complementarity of the two functions of sign; math as a SFMD; defining one’s mathematical understanding of a signifier as one’s realization tree for a mathematical signifier; MRC (multimodal representational competency)
  • Writing about My Proposal Tables

  • Old Draft

  • New Draft

  • #My Proposal Figures

  • Writing about My Proposal Figures

  • #My Proposal Appendices

  • Writing about My Proposal Appendices

  • #`What type of academic writer are you?`
    #↓

{"cards":[{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb2","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":null,"content":"#Z's Think-Writing File\n"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb3","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":null,"content":"\n#Things to Think through via Writing\n#↓"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb4","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":null,"content":"#→\n@RSM, @research action\n#- `Idea: Use Toulmin's (sp?) claim-reason-evidence-warrant structure` to guide my reasoning about and explanation of `my rough, initial, hypothesized program theory` as well as my `final, revised, evidence-informed program theory`"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb7","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb4","content":"#Booth (2008), p. 109\n`Claim-reason-evidence-warrant:`\n\". . . every argument, research or not, is built out of answers to five questions . . . questions that you must ask yourself on your reader's behalf:\n* What is my claim?\n* What reasons support my claim?\n* What evidence supports my reasons?\n* What principle makes my reasons relevant to my claim? (We call this principle a warrant.)\"\n#↓"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb6","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb7","content":"##. . . `THEREFORE`, regarding my claim as to my `hypothesized, rough, initial program theory`\n\n* I claim that ONE mechanism underlying bar diagramming is that it affords subjects the OPPORTUNITY to \"add leaves to their realization trees\" by engaging in MR (multimodal representation)\n* REASONS: distributed cognition; theory of binumeracy; appropriation of sign; UMR SOLO cycle; diagram-gesture-agency theory; embodied cognition in mathematics\n* PRINCIPLES: the complementarity of the two functions of sign; math as a SFMD; defining one's mathematical understanding of a signifier as one's realization tree for a mathematical signifier; MRC (multimodal representational competency)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":4,"parentId":null,"content":"@writing, @revising\n#My Proposal Tables, Images, and Appendices\n"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb8","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"##My Proposal Tables\n"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb8","content":"Writing about My Proposal Tables"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc5","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"#My Proposal Figures\n"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc5","content":"Writing about My Proposal Figures"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd0","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"#My Proposal Appendices"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd9","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd0","content":"Writing about My Proposal Appendices"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bda","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd9","content":"#`What type of academic writer are you?`\n#↓"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bdb","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd9","content":"[ ] Top down\n[ ] Bottom up\n[ ] Top down at first, but then . . .\n[ ] Bottom up at first, but then . . .\n[ ] Depends\n[ ] Neither\n[ ] I don't know! / Hadn't thought of it!"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd1","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.5,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-09.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd2","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.5078125,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-05.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd3","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.515625,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-04.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd4","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.53125,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-03.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd5","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.5625,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-02.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd6","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.625,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-01.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd7","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1.75,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-07.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bd8","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcf","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-00.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc6","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":11,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-19.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc7","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":12,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-18.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc8","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":13,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-17.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc9","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":14,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-16.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bca","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":15,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-15.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcb","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":16,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-14.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcc","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":17,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-13.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bcd","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":18,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-12.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bce","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":19,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc2","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-11.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc3","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb8","content":"Old Draft\n"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc4","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb8","content":"New Draft"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb9","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-21.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bba","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.5,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-28.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bbb","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-26.png)\n[Table 3]( http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-26.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bbc","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3.75,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-20.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bbd","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3.875,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-24.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bbe","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3.90625,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-23.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bbf","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3.921875,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-22.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc0","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3.9375,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-25.png)"},{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bc1","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":4,"parentId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb5","content":"![](http://theblossomingfledglingresearcher.files.wordpress.com/2014/01/proposal-tables-figures-appendices-2014jan02-no-27.png)"},{"_id":"3be2674aaa168fd4ce000224","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":5,"parentId":null,"content":"#`My Awesome Zeroeth Draft`\n#↓\n"},{"_id":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":6,"parentId":null,"content":"#Introduction →\n#↓"},{"_id":"3be26bb6aa168fd4ce000227","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"#Research Design →\n#↓"},{"_id":"3be26d61aa168fd4ce000228","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"3be26bb6aa168fd4ce000227","content":"#Conclusion →\n#↓"},{"_id":"3be26dadaa168fd4ce000229","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"3be26d61aa168fd4ce000228","content":"#{Back Matter}"},{"_id":"3be277fbaa168fd4ce000232","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Realist Synthesis Methodology\n"},{"_id":"3be286f9aa168fd4ce00023b","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.5,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"###Overview (description) of Realist Synthesis Methdology"},{"_id":"3be28830aa168fd4ce00023c","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.75,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"###Assumptions under Realist Synthesis Methdology"},{"_id":"3be2894aaa168fd4ce00023d","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.875,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"###Key Concepts in Realist Synthesis Methodology\n"},{"_id":"3be28ad5aa168fd4ce00023e","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.9375,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"###Stages in Realist Synthesis Methodology"},{"_id":"3be28bb5aa168fd4ce00023f","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.96875,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"###Challenges with Employing Realist Synthesis Methodology"},{"_id":"3be28c62aa168fd4ce000240","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":2.984375,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"###Strengths of Realist Synthesis"},{"_id":"3be27878aa168fd4ce000233","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Rationale for Employing Realist Synthesis"},{"_id":"3be27b21aa168fd4ce000234","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":4,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Methods"},{"_id":"3be28142aa168fd4ce000238","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":4.5,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Ethical Considerations"},{"_id":"3be27c77aa168fd4ce000235","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":5,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Scope and Delimitations\n`(factors under the control of the researcher)`"},{"_id":"3be27f78aa168fd4ce000237","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":5.5,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Limitations\n`(factors NOT under the control of the researcher)`"},{"_id":"3be27da4aa168fd4ce000236","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":6,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Assumptions\n`(factors that the researcher assumes are taken into consideration)`"},{"_id":"3be282c5aa168fd4ce000239","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":7,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##External Validity (Generalizability)"},{"_id":"3be2836faa168fd4ce00023a","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":8,"parentId":"3be269cbaa168fd4ce000226","content":"##Internal Validity (Reliability)"},{"_id":"3be2718eaa168fd4ce00022a","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":7,"parentId":null,"content":"##{introductory paragraphs}"},{"_id":"3be2722aaa168fd4ce00022b","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":8,"parentId":null,"content":"##Background of the Study"},{"_id":"3be2728daa168fd4ce00022c","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":9,"parentId":null,"content":"##Statement of the Problem"},{"_id":"3be2733daa168fd4ce00022d","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":10,"parentId":null,"content":"##Purpose and Rationale of the Study"},{"_id":"3be27417aa168fd4ce00022e","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":11,"parentId":null,"content":"##Research Question and Review Questions"},{"_id":"3be2bbf1aa168fd4ce000242","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":11.5,"parentId":null,"content":"###Central Research Question"},{"_id":"3be2bcc9aa168fd4ce000243","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":11.75,"parentId":null,"content":"###Review Questions\n"},{"_id":"3be274c5aa168fd4ce00022f","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":12,"parentId":null,"content":"##Some Hypotheses"},{"_id":"3be27557aa168fd4ce000230","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":13,"parentId":null,"content":"##Definition of Key Terms"},{"_id":"3be276d5aa168fd4ce000231","treeId":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","seq":1,"position":14,"parentId":null,"content":"##{preview: list of main sections and subsections}"}],"tree":{"_id":"52c9d59539d6b3d531004bb1","name":"2014January_ZYS_ZeroethDraft_DevelopingWritingAddiction","publicUrl":"2014-january-z-y-s-zero-draft-developing-writing-addiction"}}