Sign up for free to use this document yourself.

  • Platonic

  • Leibnizian

  • Lewisian

  • Aristotelian

  • What we want

  • Questions

  • Problems

  • Benefits

  • Questions

  • Problems

  • Benefits

  • Questions

  • Problems

  • Benefits

  • Questions

  • Problems

  • Benefits

  • Possible worlds

  • Possible worlds, intentionality of propositions

  • Grounding

  • Global possibilites and grounding

  • Why 1=1 is necessary

  • Causal Identity Pruss 258

  • Gives an answer to the problem of a possible world with unjustified evil.

  • Identities dependence on cause is incredibly silly.
    That would mean a number of things, that I could only be born at that time, that no different technological advances could have occurred, that my parents couldn’t have met in some different way. I don’t see how this wouldn’t involve some local determinism.

  • Exactly alike seems to entail too much and isn’t clear.

  • Trinity? Jesus is not identical with the Father, yet their causal history is the same.

{"cards":[{"_id":"378c87b8a6ab09e91700001d","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":null,"content":"Platonic"},{"_id":"378c8c8da6ab09e917000023","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378c87b8a6ab09e91700001d","content":"Questions"},{"_id":"378c8d78a6ab09e917000024","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"378c87b8a6ab09e91700001d","content":"Problems"},{"_id":"378c8e49a6ab09e917000025","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"378c87b8a6ab09e91700001d","content":"Benefits"},{"_id":"378c88f8a6ab09e917000020","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":null,"content":"Leibnizian"},{"_id":"378c8f22a6ab09e917000027","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378c88f8a6ab09e917000020","content":"Questions"},{"_id":"378c8f39a6ab09e917000028","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1.5,"parentId":"378c88f8a6ab09e917000020","content":"Problems"},{"_id":"378c8f78a6ab09e917000029","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"378c88f8a6ab09e917000020","content":"Benefits"},{"_id":"378c89c6a6ab09e917000021","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":null,"content":"Lewisian"},{"_id":"378c8fe0a6ab09e91700002a","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378c89c6a6ab09e917000021","content":"Questions"},{"_id":"378c900ba6ab09e91700002b","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"378c89c6a6ab09e917000021","content":"Problems"},{"_id":"378c902ba6ab09e91700002c","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"378c89c6a6ab09e917000021","content":"Benefits"},{"_id":"378d88e3a6ab09e91700002d","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":4,"parentId":null,"content":"Aristotelian\n"},{"_id":"378d895da6ab09e91700002e","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378d88e3a6ab09e91700002d","content":"Questions"},{"_id":"378d897da6ab09e91700002f","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"378d88e3a6ab09e91700002d","content":"Problems"},{"_id":"378d89efa6ab09e917000032","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378d897da6ab09e91700002f","content":"Causal Identity Pruss 258"},{"_id":"378d8a29a6ab09e917000033","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378d89efa6ab09e917000032","content":"Identities dependence on cause is incredibly silly.\nThat would mean a number of things, that I could only be born at that time, that no different technological advances could have occurred, that my parents couldn't have met in some different way. I don't see how this wouldn't involve some local determinism."},{"_id":"378dad46a6ab09e917000034","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378d8a29a6ab09e917000033","content":"Trinity? Jesus is not identical with the Father, yet their causal history is the same."},{"_id":"378db30ba6ab09e917000035","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"378d89efa6ab09e917000032","content":"Exactly alike seems to entail too much and isn't clear."},{"_id":"378d89a0a6ab09e917000030","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"378d88e3a6ab09e91700002d","content":"Benefits"},{"_id":"378e24b3a6ab09e917000036","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378d89a0a6ab09e917000030","content":"Gives an answer to the problem of a possible world with unjustified evil."},{"_id":"378e5556a6ab09e917000038","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":5,"parentId":null,"content":"What we want"},{"_id":"378e5d30a2d080142e000039","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":1,"parentId":"378e5556a6ab09e917000038","content":"Possible worlds"},{"_id":"378e5d57a2d080142e00003a","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":2,"parentId":"378e5556a6ab09e917000038","content":"Possible worlds, intentionality of propositions"},{"_id":"378e5de9a2d080142e00003b","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":3,"parentId":"378e5556a6ab09e917000038","content":"Grounding"},{"_id":"378e5e3aa2d080142e00003c","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":4,"parentId":"378e5556a6ab09e917000038","content":"Global possibilites and grounding"},{"_id":"378e5f15a2d080142e00003d","treeId":"35ffed65f561101990000008","seq":1,"position":5,"parentId":"378e5556a6ab09e917000038","content":"Why 1=1 is necessary"}],"tree":{"_id":"35ffed65f561101990000008","name":"Modality","publicUrl":"modality"}}